Board Thread:Warhammer 40k General Discussion/@comment-26165786-20150304163255/@comment-25869775-20150419232405

Thank you Neithan. My point stands!

Messenger of the Lion kudos to you for a fun topic.

The Fall of Caliban is evidence to Jonsons loyalty enough, despite his earlier scumbag behavior. If he did go traitor, just thinking now, he's be an Iron Warrior type of traitor not a Word Bearer type for sure. Maybe Slaanesh.....

Any loyal primarch better than Horus for Warmaste? No. He was perfect...Gulliman/like you said I think/ the only real other option. You can't tell me Dorn or Corax was a better option.

OK @ Hereticalthoughts: Gulliman, if he comes back, would take the title of Warmaster, not Jonson. I do personally think RG did kill Alpharious. I think since he fought with Horus only to defeat chaos in the future not for the cause, and ultimately failed, I think the 4 had him killed by pitting him against G, if he killed Gulliman, good for them, they'd pin him against Russ next and that would be it; if G killed him, just as good. This is because he would have lead the Alpha Legion to fight against Chaos now that the Heresy was over. Rejoining the Imperium was no longer an option for him but in the Eye he would have stayed loyal kept the legion together and E would have potentially forgiven him if lets say he annihilated two or three Traitor Legions like the World Eaters, EC, or "gasp" Sons of Horus (who were fewer than the Emperor's Children after the Heresy {this is in the Black Legion Supplement}, which he could have after the Slave Wars. The Word Bearers and Iron warriors would have shredded him, but he would have stayed clear of them. Alpharious is likely dead or in stasis too, therefore because, the Alpha Legion are now mostly traitors, barely organized, and never seem to work against Chaos. Some are being absorbed into the BL and WB too. Plus Omegon was loyal and went to Titan so he's not leading the legion. This is my theory.