Board Thread:Warhammer 40k General Discussion/@comment-27642965-20160211003725/@comment-8881468-20191107110532

1. let's go for some stuff that shows holes in SW A. Obi Wan knows where luke and Leia are and does 0 in terms of getting both of them trained in the force until one of them is an adult

B. luke and leia are "hidden" in plain sight, Leia actually as senator spending a lot of time in the presence of the emperor, who, like vader is able to sense people strong in the force. and luke keeps his name and sits down with anakin's "step family", well hidden indeed.

C. the emperor sends plans of the death star (rotj) to the rebellion which show a weakness in the DS, why not send altered plans that reveal false weaknesses, which would be more in line with the whole "it's a trap" thing

D. in anh leia knows they are being tracked when they leave  the death star in the falcon  in ANH, why not switch ships instead of leading the empire directly to the hidden rebellion  base...

E Lando,  Chewie and Leia are completely superfluous to all events in Jabba's palace, as the only thing neede for killing Jabba is Luke getting his lightsabre, which is in R2D2

F the force works, except when it does not, f.e. whenever Luke does not use the forece to pull blasters from opponents, get out of ewok nets, kill the rancor by using the foprce to push a button on a panel or interact with the mechanisms of the door, instead it is "throw somehting at a panel"

G funny how from potential love interest in ANH and ESB (remember the kiss after the wampa attack), Leia goes over to "I know luke was my brother all along"...

H vader disables the falcon's hyperdrive in cloud cityx, why not disable the whole falcon and prevent it form being able to take off in the first palce, if you plan to prevent their escape.

I: why no use he death star to blast through yavin in ANH instead of waiting all the time to get around the planet. it is a meaningless gas giant anyway.

J funny how Leia and Luke do not mourn for their families when they are killed. Luke shows more grief when Obi Wan dies, whom he had only known for a couple of days at best.

K should we really go into something as basic as: nobody remembers jedi anyore, when in fact the jedi have only been destroyed what ~20 years ago (luke and leia's age)

-- there is easily more shoddy writing in there (and don't get us started about the dialogue and "acting".. as the key about acting is doing things instead of telling people what you're going to do/what is on your mind. when the writer does no trust you to be with the character that much, f..ew the scenes with luke talking to vader and the "there is still good in you" is so bad it ain't funny anymore.

2. really, shooting torps at a planet is only used in the worst cases? orbital bombardment only defines the height of origin of weapon's fire as a whole... "bombard from orbit"

3. once again: proivide us with source material that supports your claim.

4. so how about you produce the articles (and this wiki is only a secondary source, which compiles primary source material, so showing us the primarty source material should be easy for you. put your money where your mouth is.

5. an article is an object, it cannot have an opinion and as the article  is merely a reproduction of primary source material (Star Wars design schemata etc) it is not an opinion but a statement of fact of official primary source material. AKA SW says it is a particle beam, so it is a particle beam. Which has much more dcredibility than your statements thus far.

bullets fly in ballistic curves, which is an established fact and is used f.e. when adjusting aim for something as simple as bullet drop (as gravity exerts it's influence over a projectile and like several other forces, changes trajectory) or did you skip physics classes in school?

let's take a simple example, throwing a javelin https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Cfzy1XlmVA notice how the throw is aimed upwards, yet the javelin itself moves along a curved path and makes it back to the ground? Which means that you can thow a spear or a cannonball OVER an obstacle,unlike a beam, as the beam only moves forward in a straight line. which means: if there is somehting between you and your target when using a beam weapon, your shots will only hit that obstacle.

6. based on what? The death star is now more durable than a whole planet? Source?

Funny how you still fail to come up with anyhting of substance instead of unsupported claims.

Debate 101: Support your claims with facts and evidence which is absent from your fanboy delusions.

facts do not care about your delusions