Board Thread:Warhammer 40k General Discussion/@comment-5781149-20130130013422/@comment-4948356-20130523181755

I don't think any of them would surpass the other overall. Despite what I say about Cain

They are the Three best commissars Ever written about, without question. (well, aside from my internet avatar, but thats different :P)

Each are the best in their own way:

Yarrick is hands down the most badass for many reasons. Power Claw, Laser eye, so on so forth.

Gaunt is on of the best leaders the imperium has seen.

and Cain is Cain, No agrument. Cain is one of the most unique commissars seen in the galaxy. Also, as far as I can tell, he's faced MORE than gaunt and Yarrick, at least until eiher of them get another book at some point, thats not of chaos or orks.

Yarrick deals with orks, almost exculsivily.

Gaunt's pretty much chaos.

Cain faced: Orks, Chaos, Eldar, Dark Eldar, Tyranids, and the Necrons... kinda. Plus, unlike Yarrick and Gaunt, he's funny which wins bonus points.

Overall:

Yarrick= Total Badass

Guant= Great Leader

Cain= Most Popular

I love all three, but Cain is my personal favorite, aside from my own.