Board Thread:Warhammer 40k General Discussion/@comment-25618639-20150325213156/@comment-86.147.151.188-20150328190329

Sigismund is a main contender I think. He was remarked as like death himself by the Blood Angels Primarch and killed dozens in the melee of the Battle of Terra.

Lucius was killed and has been killed a few times, the only reason he comes back is a magic trick, no real skill in that part. He was beaten by a RavenGuard then later killed by him in the Angel Exterminus novel. I would have expected someone so gooby about certain parts of this same book would recall such a thing as Lucius dying. As this is a sparring cage quote, Sigismund also beat Lucius moraly as Lucius punched him to draw the fight as he recalls he couldn't win.

I highly doubt Amit (Nassir Amit?) as he was a Blood Angel so in the same breathe you'd have expected Sanguinius to praise Sigismund, you'd have expected him to say 'like death himself...or my mate Amit even...". So no you are pretty much wrong.