User blog comment:Raffney/Timetravel in 40k OR is the Emperor a Chaos God?/@comment-2125941-20180226163347

"Lorgar was shwn a vision of thins that might come to pass, not more not less, chaos wished to influence him. "

I get your point and it's totally possible but there is equally no definite proof to support that it was not.

"The chaos gods are emotions made manifest. None of them was a creature in the materium that then got power in the immaterium. They are merely the "personified" amalgamation of an emotion. Slanesh is merely the concentrated essence of sensation in all it's facets, pleasure or pain, hate and love, tipped over the edge into creation by murderfucking of eldar. There was never a consciousness in the materium, from which slanesh evolved, all that happened without control in the immaterium."

I know and on a solely pragmatic view of things i agree, it certainly would denie what i said. But that's why i called it a theory! Theories are hardly pragmatic.

" The creation of the chaos gods themselves as avatars of their respective aspects/facets makes them immortal and indestructible, unless you kill of all life that creates the warp. "

There is also no solid proof for that. Eldar gods could be destroyed for example. I know they are different than Chaos. But does that mean the Eldar are really deluding themselfs into believing Ynnead could destroy Slaanesh one day to free them if Chaos Gods really can't die unless you murder all life? Or do you think Ynnead the god of death will murder all life to accomplish that? Or does the Eldar knew more than us about Chaos?

I don't know what GW stated about it but it gives me some food for thought: Let's say on a theoretical base Nurgle would be destroyed some day..but then out of the same spectrum of emotions would evolve million years later another plague god to take his place. Would that automatically again be Nurgle or would that be another deity? How much personality does a Chaos god really have?

Maybe i'm overthinking that stuff a bit but it makes fun and i like 40k lore.