Board Thread:Warhammer 40k General Discussion/@comment-7699236-20150618150629/@comment-7699236-20151214221908

Aldaron The Hunter 96 wrote: @TomB12, what the hell are you talking about? I'm not even sure were to begin... 1-female marines never existed. 2-The Emperor was not in a dire situation during the Great Crusade, that was the Age of Strife, He was at his prime during the Crusade, shows how much you know about the lore. 3- He did chose every single thunder warrior and terran marine carefully. He never just pooled recruits. 4-There was never any female Astartes. 5- There are no frozen lady marines. Stop that. 6-This is not the fan fiction site. 6- No that would actually be a very boring series. 7- Not all chaos marines want to destroy the imperium, many want to convert it to chaos, That was Lorgar's idea! 8- "Because chaos" is not an argument. 8- All the Primarch's were male. 9- It would be a shame is GW destroyed their franchise with bullcrap like that.

@ Neithan02, Black Library is cannon. Sisters of Battle are augmented super soldiers. Everything I stated stands. Sorry, I should have mentioned it was a theory based on musings and wishful thinking. I have no support for it.

Secondly, when I said Great Crusade I should have said Unification Wars. While it is true that he'd handpick every Thunder Warrior recruit, I still think he'd pick some women to enhance. And in the end he kills them all (except a few) so we don't know a lot about them.

Thirdly, because Chaos seems like an argument that put into context can stand up more or less on it's own legs. Have you seen the stuff that goes on in the Warp?

Fourthly, a lot of the knowledge of the Great Crusade was either lost after the Horus Heresy or replaced with dogma to better suit the Imperium's needs and wants. And there's the two hidden Primarchs too.

Fifthly, I do not see how GW would destroy their franchise by doing that. If they did it carefully, elaborately, then it could pull off. I'm not asking for a whole new faction. Just some different models at the most and just simple canon that they do exist at the least. Masculine fanboys can ignore them if they want and people who are interested in the concept can explore it, although I am resigned to the fact that this probably will never get off the ground.

Lastly, you have not refuted the possibility of a Chaos warband creating female Space Marines. I mean, look at the Daemonculaba that Honsou had. Technically they are female Space Marines, and no one ever tried putting a girl in one of them.

And also try not to repeat arguments, and work on your writing skills a tiny bit more. It won't change how true you are, but looking a bit more credible never hurt.